Oprah Winfrey's New Network: What the Critics Think
Oprah Winfrey launched her new cable channel at noon Saturday. So what do the critics have to say about it, now that it's all of a day old?
The Associated Press' Frazier Moore commented on the "rather quiet" launch of OWN: The Oprah Winfrey Network after more than two years of planning and "months of hype."
Adding that the network kicked off with a Winfrey-hosted one-hour preview special that was "free of glitz," Moore wrote, "The strategy seemed that of a soft opening, aimed at whetting viewers' appetites so they regularly come back and sample the network's expanding menu of new shows as they roll out." [Related: Oprah Winfrey on why she "had a lot of anxiety" about launching a network]
Meanwhile, the New York Times' Alessandra Stanley called the channel a "no cynicism zone."
The unveiling, Stanley wrote, "was most striking for what it lacked: Nowhere in that opening gush of feel-good highlight reels, self-improvement plans, spiritual quests, aha! moments, celebrity master classes and people finding their truths and living their own best lives was there a snicker of malice or a hint of raillery."
Stanley went on to write that "OWN is a place where cynicism takes a holiday and mockery hasn’t yet been invented."
Caryn James wrote on IndieWire.com that OWN "displays a whiff of spirituality, a huge amount of life-style fluff and a surprising layer of substance."
James wrote that only die-hard Winfrey fans would like most of the programs that air on the network, which ranges from shows on cooking and how to unclutter your home to celebrity-themed series starring Sarah Ferguson and Shania Twain. But she had praise for Oprah Presents Master Class, which features accomplished people including Jay-Z and Diane Sawyer reflecting on how they achieved success.
One of the more negative reviews came from Jennifer Mabry in a critique on the Root, an online publication that targets a black audience. Mabry wrote that she could sum up her feelings in one word: "disappointed."
Winfrey "seems content to follow the new television model of programming that exploded in the wake of the 2008 Hollywood writers' strike: Find anyone with a heartbeat and a willingness to have cameras follow them during their ordinary day-to-day life, and voilà -- we've got ourselves a TV show!" Mabry wrote.
She added that this seemed to be a "missed opportunity," arguing that the network should instead air original scripted programming targeted to "upwardly mobile, upper-middle-class black folk."
Matt Zoller Seitz offered up a rather snarky review on Salon.com that was interspersed with declarations about his hangover- (and OWN-?) induced headache.
"One of the more disquieting aspects ... is the pervasive sense (inevitable, I suppose) that this cable network is not just a programming venture and a brand extension, but a living monument to its creator's power -- and a celebration of her willingness to use that power as a force for good," he wrote. "We won't just watch OWN; we will gaze upon it with awe and affection and marvel at the sweet magnificence of its founder."
OWN, a joint venture between Winfrey and Discovery Communications, replaced Discovery Health Channel on cable and satellite systems and is available in 85 million homes.
Hollywood Goes Broadway
What Hollywood Earns
What's Hot in TV
- Winnie and Kevin Probably Slept Together and 11 Other Things We Learned at Last Night’s Wonder Years Reunion
- How Much Do You Know About American Horror Story? Take Our SAT Exam
- Garage Doors and Tanning Beds: 9 Actors Remember Their Famous Horror-Movie Deaths
- It’s Just a Normal Tuesday With Drake and ILoveMakonnen
- 'Ouija' Movie Stars Attend Spooky Seance with Their Celeb Pals (Exclusive Video!)
- Justin Timberlake & Jessica Biel Settle Lawsuit Against Tabloid Publishing False Stories
- Renee Zellweger Brings Her Boyfriend Doyle Bramhall II to Elle Women in Hollywood Event!
- Nikki Reed & Emmy Rossum Stun at Elle Women in Hollywood Celebration