5:26pm PT by Andy Lewis
1936 Oscar Outprices Rare Golden Globe and Tony Awards at Auction
An Oscar--even a cracked and scratched--is still the most valuable trophy in entertainment as evidenced by recent auction results.
An unremarkable Oscar garnered a siginificant higher price than Marlon Brando's Golden Globe and Helen Hayes' Tony award.
The 1936 Academy Award Charles MacArthur won for "best story" for his screenplay for The Scoundrel sold for $106,231 at an auction at Nate D. Sanders on April 2.
The statue was in poor condition with cracking in the head and ankles.
Since 1950, AMPAS has required Oscar winners have been required to sign a contract to offer their Oscar to the Academy for a nominal fee before trying to sell it on the open market.
Pre-1950 Oscars, like this one, are exempt from the rule.
Orson Welles' award for Citizen Kane went for $861,542 in 2011. Screenwriter Herman Mankiewicz's best screenplay Oscar (also for Citizen Kane) fetched $588,545 in 2012.
Marlon Brando's 1954 Golden Globe for On the Waterfront fetched $68,500 at a March 30 auction conducted by Heritage Auctions.