The Deleted 'Jedi' Line That Redeemed Obi-Wan Kenobi
In an alternate version of the third "Star Wars" movie, Yoda revealed a slight schism in the Jedi Order over Darth Vader's secret identity.
One of the unspoken truths about the Star Wars cycle of movies is that Yoda and Obi-Wan Kenobi are jerks. Just reading those words seems like heresy, I know, but think about it: They lied to Luke Skywalker to manipulate him into considering Darth Vader an enemy to be beaten, rather than the former ally -- and Luke's father -- that he really was. Clearly, whoever taught the ethics class at the Jedi Academy needed a refresher course of their own.
Things may not have been as bad as they seemed from the final cuts of each movie, however. A deleted scene from Return of the Jedi has appeared online as part of an ongoing fan project to digitize the special features from an out-of-print LaserDisc version of the movie, and in it, there's a hint that at least Obi-Wan felt the deception wasn't necessarily the best idea.
On his death bed, Yoda tells an offscreen Luke that "Obi-Wan would have told you [about the true fate of Anakin Skywalker] long ago, had I let him." It's a small detail, admittedly, but one that casts Kenobi as a bit less of a jerk -- and changes the previously harmonious relationship between Kenobi and Yoda slightly, as well.
Of course, the line didn't make the cut (literally), leaving this reading of the relationship entirely non-canonical … at least until one of the rumored Star Wars prequels decides to add this kind of disharmony back in. It's hardly out of the question.
Sundance: On the Scene