Get THR Mobile Alerts        FREE Newsletters
Film Reviews
Film Review: The Tale of Despereaux
By Michael Rechtshaffen, December 15, 2008 05:00 ET
 
Rate This Film
55
1 User Reviews
» See all
» Write a Review
0 User Comments
» See all
» Leave a Comment
 
Cast and Crew
Executive Producer: William Sargent
Executive Producer: Robin Bissell
Executive Producer: Ryan Kavanaugh
Executive Producer: David Lipman
Producer: Allison Thomas
Producer: Gary Ross
Co-producer: Tracy Shaw
Associate producer: Cecil Boydell
Director: Sam Fell
Director: Rob Stevenhagen
Screen Writer: Gary Ross
Director of Photography: Brad Blackbourn
Editor: Mark Solomon
Prod. Designer: Evgeni Tomov
Music: William Ross
Casting director: Debra Zane
Cast: Matthew Broderick (Despereaux), Dustin Hoffman (Roscuro), Emma Watson (Princess Pea), Tracey Ullman (Miggery Sow), Kevin Kline (Andre), William H. Macy (Lester), Stanley Tucci (Boldo), Ciaran Hinds (Botticelli), Robbie Coltrane (Gregory), Christopher Lloyd (Hovis), Tony Hale (Furlough), Sigourney Weaver (Narrator)
See Full Chart
Box Office:
Week of 03/01/2009
Pos.: 42 Gross: $135,145
Bottom Line: The magic is minuscule in this handsome-looking but drearily told animated tale.
There's a fitting aura of gloom and despair surrounding "The Tale of Despereaux," a decidedly unfrilly fairy tale about a tiny mouse with large ears and a larger heart who finds redemption in a kingdom of darkness.

Although the artfully rendered CG animation is quite lovely, the less-than-enchanting scripting is another story.

In making the leap to the big screen from Kate DiCamillo's Newbery Medal-winning 2003 novel, "The Tale of Despereaux: Being the Story of a Mouse, a Princess, Some Soup and a Spool of Thread," a considerable amount of magic and charm appears to have gotten lost in the translation.

What remains -- particularly the rodent and the soup part -- can't help but invite comparisons to "Ratatouille," and not in a favorable way.

Given the absence of fresh animated fare, families might still initially take the bait, but the picture's murkier recesses could prove too intense for the kiddies.

Co-directed by Sam Fell, who went the rat route with the entertaining "Flushed Away," and first-timer Rob Stevenhagen, the film centers on one Despereaux Tilling (voiced by Matthew Broderick), a brave little mouse whose un-mouse-like behavior -- he's known to converse with humans and prefers to read books rather than eat them -- lands him in big trouble.

He's banished from the Mouseworld and sent to the much darker Ratworld, presided over by the sinister Botticelli (Ciaran Hinds), who bears a strong resemblance to Nosferatu (or would that be NosfeRATu?).

Fortunately, he's shown the ropes by another recent arrival, Roscuro, a Ratso Rizzo sort of a rat, voiced, natch, by Dustin Hoffman, while finding himself smitten with the fair, human Princess Pea (Emma Watson), who's a virtual prisoner in her father's grim castle.

Despereaux ultimately will rise to those necessarily heroic heights, but the film strangely never follows suit.

Although screenwriter Gary Ross has done well with underdogs ("Seabiscuit," "Dave"), in adapting the DiCamillo novel it's as if he and co-directors Fell and Stevenhagen cut off the tale with a carving knife.

The transitions between the parallel Despereaux and Roscuro stories are choppy, while the rest of the characters never feel satisfyingly developed despite the best efforts of an all-star voice cast including Tracey Ullman, Kevin Kline, William H. Macy and Frank Langella.

Sigourney Weaver, meanwhile, handles the curiously detached narration.

The flatly generic results certainly appear at odds with the picture's stirring visual style, which pays homage to the great Flemish artists, while lending a remarkable warmth missing in most computer-generated enterprises.
Film Review: The Tale of Despereaux
By Michael Rechtshaffen, December 15, 2008 05:00 ET
Bottom Line: The magic is minuscule in this handsome-looking but drearily told animated tale.
There's a fitting aura of gloom and despair surrounding "The Tale of Despereaux," a decidedly unfrilly fairy tale about a tiny mouse with large ears and a larger heart who finds redemption in a kingdom of darkness.

Although the artfully rendered CG animation is quite lovely, the less-than-enchanting scripting is another story.

In making the leap to the big screen from Kate DiCamillo's Newbery Medal-winning 2003 novel, "The Tale of Despereaux: Being the Story of a Mouse, a Princess, Some Soup and a Spool of Thread," a considerable amount of magic and charm appears to have gotten lost in the translation.

What remains -- particularly the rodent and the soup part -- can't help but invite comparisons to "Ratatouille," and not in a favorable way.

Given the absence of fresh animated fare, families might still initially take the bait, but the picture's murkier recesses could prove too intense for the kiddies.

Co-directed by Sam Fell, who went the rat route with the entertaining "Flushed Away," and first-timer Rob Stevenhagen, the film centers on one Despereaux Tilling (voiced by Matthew Broderick), a brave little mouse whose un-mouse-like behavior -- he's known to converse with humans and prefers to read books rather than eat them -- lands him in big trouble.

He's banished from the Mouseworld and sent to the much darker Ratworld, presided over by the sinister Botticelli (Ciaran Hinds), who bears a strong resemblance to Nosferatu (or would that be NosfeRATu?).

Fortunately, he's shown the ropes by another recent arrival, Roscuro, a Ratso Rizzo sort of a rat, voiced, natch, by Dustin Hoffman, while finding himself smitten with the fair, human Princess Pea (Emma Watson), who's a virtual prisoner in her father's grim castle.

Despereaux ultimately will rise to those necessarily heroic heights, but the film strangely never follows suit.

Although screenwriter Gary Ross has done well with underdogs ("Seabiscuit," "Dave"), in adapting the DiCamillo novel it's as if he and co-directors Fell and Stevenhagen cut off the tale with a carving knife.

The transitions between the parallel Despereaux and Roscuro stories are choppy, while the rest of the characters never feel satisfyingly developed despite the best efforts of an all-star voice cast including Tracey Ullman, Kevin Kline, William H. Macy and Frank Langella.

Sigourney Weaver, meanwhile, handles the curiously detached narration.

The flatly generic results certainly appear at odds with the picture's stirring visual style, which pays homage to the great Flemish artists, while lending a remarkable warmth missing in most computer-generated enterprises.
1 of 1 Pages
1
 


Post a Comment
Asterisk (*) is a required field.
* Username: 
Rate This Article: (1=Bad, 5=Perfect)

*Comment:
Videos
The Hollywood Reporter Key Art Awards honor excellence in movie marketing.; Key Art Awards; Promotion; marketing; Reviews Index http://link.brightcove.com/services/link/bcpid1078667197http://www.brightcove.com/channel.jsp?channel=769341148
THR on DIGG