EDITIONS:   US| Int’l | Asia | Print
Get THR Mobile Alerts        FREE Newsletters
Music Reviews
Pete Seeger 90th Birthday Concert at Madison Square Garden -- Concert Review
By Frank Scheck, May 04, 2009 05:38 ET
Arlo Guthrie and Bruce Springsteen play Pete Seeger's 90th birthday concert (Getty Images photo)
Bottom Line: A historic concert celebrating one of America's musical icons.
NEW YORK -- There was an appropriate egalitarianism on display Sunday at the 90th birthday tribute concert to Pete Seeger at Madison Square Garden. Superstars including Bruce Springsteen, Dave Matthews and John Mellencamp received no more stage time than such veteran acts as Arlo Guthrie, Joan Baez, Richie Havens and many others. The 4 1/2-hour show, thankfully filmed for broadcast on PBS in the summer, paid suitable tribute to the folk music legend and tireless political activist.

It also served as a fundraiser for the Hudson River Sloop Clearwater, the organization Seeger founded to preserve and protect the Hudson River.

Most of the older performers had worked with the guest of honor, but even the younger ones had personal connections with him. Mellencamp introduced his solo rendition of "If I Had a Hammer (The Hammer Song)" by announcing it was the first song he learned to play on guitar. And Matthews, before unveiling an impressive falsetto on "Rye Whiskey," commented that Seeger headlined the first concert he ever attended.

Springsteen, who released a Seeger tribute album a few years back, talked at length about a man who he described as "looking like your 90-year-old grandpa, if your grandpa could kick your ass!" More seriously, he said, "At 90, he remains a stealth dagger into the country's illusions about itself." Springsteen then sang his "The Ghost of Tom Joad" as a duet with Tom Morello.

With many of the performers joining together for group numbers, the evening's highlights were numerous. They included a haunting "Fare Thee Well," performed by Rufus Wainwright, Teddy Thompson, the McGarrigle Sisters and Bruce Cockburn; a dazzling banjo medley by Bela Fleck and Tony Trischka, which playfully included "Happy Birthday to You"; Joan Baez, showcasing her still-lustrous voice with the still-relevant "Where Have All the Flowers Gone?"; Billy Bragg's a cappella rendition of "The Internationale," with his own rewritten lyrics; a rousing "We Shall Overcome," led by Seeger; Kris Kristofferson and Ani DiFranco's amusing duet on the children's song "Hole in the Bucket"; Richie Havens, looking like a biblical prophet, reprising his hit "Freedom"; and a killer lineup of Taj Mahal, Toshi Reagon, Steve Earle, Warren Haynes and Seeger trading verses on "Sailin' Up, Sailin' Down."

Although Seeger didn't sing all that much, he did lead the capacity audience on several sing-alongs, advising them, "There's no such thing as a wrong note."

The entire musical lineup -- which also included Roger McGuinn, Emmylou Harris, Ben Harper, Michael Franti, Dar Williams, Tom Paxton, the Preservation Hall Jazz Band and even Oscar the Grouch from "Sesame Street," among many others -- gathered together for "This Land Is Your Land." Suitably enough for a singer of whom Springsteen said, "He sings all the verses, all the time, especially the ones we want to leave out of our history," this rendition of the Woody Guthrie classic included even the obscure verses normally omitted.

Venue: Madison Square Garden, New York (Sunday, May 3)
Pete Seeger 90th Birthday Concert at Madison Square Garden -- Concert Review
By Frank Scheck, May 04, 2009 05:38 ET
Arlo Guthrie and Bruce Springsteen play Pete Seeger's 90th birthday concert (Getty Images photo)
Bottom Line: A historic concert celebrating one of America's musical icons.
NEW YORK -- There was an appropriate egalitarianism on display Sunday at the 90th birthday tribute concert to Pete Seeger at Madison Square Garden. Superstars including Bruce Springsteen, Dave Matthews and John Mellencamp received no more stage time than such veteran acts as Arlo Guthrie, Joan Baez, Richie Havens and many others. The 4 1/2-hour show, thankfully filmed for broadcast on PBS in the summer, paid suitable tribute to the folk music legend and tireless political activist.

It also served as a fundraiser for the Hudson River Sloop Clearwater, the organization Seeger founded to preserve and protect the Hudson River.

Most of the older performers had worked with the guest of honor, but even the younger ones had personal connections with him. Mellencamp introduced his solo rendition of "If I Had a Hammer (The Hammer Song)" by announcing it was the first song he learned to play on guitar. And Matthews, before unveiling an impressive falsetto on "Rye Whiskey," commented that Seeger headlined the first concert he ever attended.

Springsteen, who released a Seeger tribute album a few years back, talked at length about a man who he described as "looking like your 90-year-old grandpa, if your grandpa could kick your ass!" More seriously, he said, "At 90, he remains a stealth dagger into the country's illusions about itself." Springsteen then sang his "The Ghost of Tom Joad" as a duet with Tom Morello.

With many of the performers joining together for group numbers, the evening's highlights were numerous. They included a haunting "Fare Thee Well," performed by Rufus Wainwright, Teddy Thompson, the McGarrigle Sisters and Bruce Cockburn; a dazzling banjo medley by Bela Fleck and Tony Trischka, which playfully included "Happy Birthday to You"; Joan Baez, showcasing her still-lustrous voice with the still-relevant "Where Have All the Flowers Gone?"; Billy Bragg's a cappella rendition of "The Internationale," with his own rewritten lyrics; a rousing "We Shall Overcome," led by Seeger; Kris Kristofferson and Ani DiFranco's amusing duet on the children's song "Hole in the Bucket"; Richie Havens, looking like a biblical prophet, reprising his hit "Freedom"; and a killer lineup of Taj Mahal, Toshi Reagon, Steve Earle, Warren Haynes and Seeger trading verses on "Sailin' Up, Sailin' Down."

Although Seeger didn't sing all that much, he did lead the capacity audience on several sing-alongs, advising them, "There's no such thing as a wrong note."

The entire musical lineup -- which also included Roger McGuinn, Emmylou Harris, Ben Harper, Michael Franti, Dar Williams, Tom Paxton, the Preservation Hall Jazz Band and even Oscar the Grouch from "Sesame Street," among many others -- gathered together for "This Land Is Your Land." Suitably enough for a singer of whom Springsteen said, "He sings all the verses, all the time, especially the ones we want to leave out of our history," this rendition of the Woody Guthrie classic included even the obscure verses normally omitted.

Venue: Madison Square Garden, New York (Sunday, May 3)
1 of 1 Pages
1
The Billboard Hot 100
Issue Date: 2010-03-27
This Week Last Week Title, Artist
Imprint | Catalog No. | Distributing Label
Peak
Position
Weeks
on
Chart
1 4 Rude Boy, Rihanna 
SRP/Def Jam DIGITAL | IDJMG |
1 5
2 2 Need You Now, Lady Antebellum  2
Capitol Nashville/Capitol DIGITAL |
2 31
3 1 Break Your Heart, Taio Cruz Featuring Ludacris 
Mercury DIGITAL | IDJMG |
1 3
4 5 Imma Be, The Black Eyed Peas 
Interscope DIGITAL |
1 15
5 16 Nothin' On You, B.o.B Featuring Bruno Mars 
RebelRock/Grand Hustle DIGITAL | Atlantic |
5 7
Source: Billboard View Full Chart »
 


Post a Comment
Asterisk (*) is a required field.
* Username: 
Rate This Article: (1=Bad, 5=Perfect)

*Comment:
Videos
THR on DIGG
Music Reviews
Albums Reviews
  • Amar la Trama
    On Jorge Drexler's latest album, "Amar la Trama," the Uruguayan singer/songwriter —perhaps best-known for his Academy Award-winning song "Al Otro Lado del Rio" from the 2004 film "The Motorcycle Diaries"—delivers another set that encourages repeated listening.
  • Tomorrow, in a Year
    Given the increasing sophistication of the Knife's recent live shows—not to mention the outright performance-art weirdness of singer Karin Dreijer Andersson's other musical project, Fever Ray—it makes sense that this Swedish electro-pop duo would turn to opera for its follow-up to its 2006 breakout album, "Silent Shout."
  • Battle of the Sexes
    Originally conceived as a sort of Marvin-and-Tammi-style collaboration between Ludacris and Shawnna, "Battle of the Sexes" shifted game plan after Shawnna decamped from Luda's Disturbing Tha Peace crew in 2009.
Singles Reviews
  • Tightrope
    To say that Janelle Monáe merges R&B, funk and rock'n'roll isn't enough—she's simply ahead of her time.
  • A Father's Love (The Only Way He Knew How)
    Bucky Covington leveraged his stint on the fifth season of "American Idol" as a springboard to a country career. His 2007 Lyric Street debut bowed at No.
  • Oh! Centra
    If vintage Nintendo 64 characters Yoshi and Donkey Kong convened in a Brooklyn junk shop and concocted a bouncy summer anthem from found parts, the result might sound something like "Oh! Centra."
Concerts Reviews
  • Neil Young Trunk Show -- Film Review
    Following up on 2006's "Neil Young: Heart of Gold" with the second film in an anticipated concert trilogy, Jonathan Demme returns with "Neil Young Trunk Show: Scenes From a Concert," an appreciably more visceral and spontaneous documentary.
  • The Music of the Who -- Concert Review
    Producer Michael Dorf's annual tributes to musical legends have become a highlight of the New York concert scene, and this show saluting "The Music of the Who" was no exception.
  • Dreamgirls -- Theater Review
    Any staging of the musical "Dreamgirls" has a lot of history to contend with. The current revival, playing a limited run at the Apollo Theater before beginning a national tour and a possible return to Broadway, is unlikely to erase anyone's memories.