Toby Keith to 'American Idol': Thanks, But No Thanks

Greg Watermann

As the American Idol rumor mill swirls into a chaotic mess of names from every genre imaginable, it seems the country contingent is leading the pack of potential judges, much like the show itself has been skewing in recent years. And can you blame the producers? All but two Idol winners hail from the South and just about every one of them (with the exception of maybe Ruben Studdard) has tried their hand at twang.

our editor recommends

'American Idol' Takes on Mariah Carey: 6 Stellar Covers of Her Hits (Video)

Aerosmith, Run-D.M.C.'s Darryl 'D.M.C.' McDaniels Reunite for 'Walk This Way' (Video)

'American Idol' Summer Tour Hits Los Angeles: Concert Review

Jordin Sparks on the Changes at 'American Idol'

So it comes as little surprise that Toby Keith would be approached as a possible contender for Steven Tyler's seat.

PHOTOS: 'American Idol' Live: The 2012 Tour In Pictures

And there is certainly merit to the choice: he’s never hesitated for a second to say what’s on his mind, whether that has to do with his feelings about Nashville as a whole or Natalie Maines individually. His talent as a songwriter is well regarded even by those who don’t savor his politics. Keith’s no stranger to being in front of a camera, between making a string of country’s most interesting videos, having been the lead in a feature, and co-hosting the CMT Awards this year. Virtually every military family in the nation regards him as a hero for his overseas visits. And he’s been filling arenas for more than a decade. Controversial and reliable? That’s a rare combination.

VIDEO: Jordin Sparks on the Changes at 'American Idol'

But according to a recent interview, he passed on the opportunity to sit alongside Mariah Carey. Keith reveals to California's Inland Empire Weekly (via examiner.com) that in early July, Idol brass asked if he'd be interested in judging the Fox show, but like so many others, the country superstar declined because of Idol's demanding schedule, opting to use his time for other endeavors -- like touring. 

VIDEO: Mariah Carey Will Be a 'Wonderful' 'American Idol' Judge, Says Haley Reinhart

It could be for the best. After all, compared to the more overt charm of a Blake Shelton or Brad Paisley, Keith's rarely smiling, roughneck image may seem a little harsh. And however much he finesses that “we’ll put a boot in your ass, it’s the American way” song and claims to be a Southern Democrat, his politics would be a turn-off factor for some blue-state viewers.

Indeed, it looks to be an election year on Idol, too. Who would get your vote for judge?

Twitter: @Idol_Worship