'The Lying Game': Theresa's Disappearance Pits Brother Against Brother (Exclusive Video)

Where is Theresa?

our editor recommends

'Lying Game's' Ryan Rottman on Season 2: 'It's Going to Get Dirty'

Charisma Carpenter on 'The Lying Game' Season 2: It Gets 'Real Juicy, Real Fast'

'Lying Game' Boss on Season 2: Rebecca's Motives, Love Shifts and a 'Shocking' Finale

'The Lying Game' Boss Reveals Big Death in Season 2

As the second season of ABC Family's The Lying Game begins to wind down, the whereabouts of Dan's (Tyler Christopher) missing fiancee is starting to cause major rifts between him and his younger brother Ethan (Blair Redford).

STORY: 'Lying Game's' Ryan Rottman on Season 2: 'It's Going to Get Dirty'

In a scene from Tuesday's episode, "The Grave Truth," Ethan starts questioning Dan about Ted's (Andy Buckley) visit to the police station. Word has it Ted and Theresa (Yara Martinez) had an encounter before she disappeared. Dan starts to reveal the context of Ted's visit before he realizes that Ethan may have other avenues of communication, namely Sutton (Alexandra Chando).

When Dan realizes that Ethan chose Sutton over his own flesh and blood, the elder Whitehorse doesn't take it very well. "You are my brother!" Dan yells. "You lied right to my face."

Will the brothers make amends? More importantly, will they find Theresa before it's too late?

The Lying Game airs at 9 p.m. Tuesdays on ABC Family.

E-mail: Philiana.Ng@thr.com
Twitter: @insidethetube