• The Hollywood Reporter on LinkedIn
  • Follow THR on Pinterest
Populaire - film still

Populaire: Rome Review

2:27 PM PST 11/11/2012 by Jordan Mintzer

The Bottom Line

Regis Roinsard’s impressive debut is a love letter to 50s filmmaking, but one that lacks a real heart.

Venue

Rome Film Festival (Out of Competition)

Cast

Romain Duris, Deborah Francois, Berenice Bejo, Shaun Benson

Writer-Director

Regis Roinsard

Romain Duris and Deborah Francois headline this retro rom-com from first-time director Regis Roinsard.

ROME -- Mad Men meets The Artist in Populaire, a superbly crafted, finely acted but somewhat shallow retro rom-com about a young French secretary who, with the help of her highly persuasive boss, hammers her way to becoming one of the fastest typists on the planet.

This impressive debut feature from writer-director Regis Roinsard is boosted by terrific lead turns from Romain Duris and Deborah Francois (The Page Turner), as well as some stunning old-school cinematography from Michel Hazanavicius regular Guillaume Schiffman. Still, there’s something formulaic and all too overtly crowd-pleasing about this sepia-toned tale of female empowerment and lost love, making for a rather soulless affair that should still stir up solid numbers at home and abroad, with TWC releasing Stateside sometime next year.

Set in the rain-swept towns of Lower Normandy in 1958, the film makes its throwback status heard loud and clear from the get-go, with opening credits (directed by Alexandre Courtes, Asylum Blackout) straight out of a Billy Wilder movie and decors and a color palette that would please the likes of both Alfred Hitchcock and Matthew Weiner. Indeed, it’s easy to spend most of the movie simply gawking at the sets (by Sylvie Olive) and costumes (by Charlotte David), so Roinsard, along with co-writers Daniel Presley and Romain Compingt, deserves credit for weaving an amusing intrigue that never lets up until the closing half-hour, when his premise starts to grow old.

A quick intro presents small-town gal Rose Pamphyle (Francois, channeling the feistier side of Grace Kelly), who works at her dad’s local grocery store but longs for a better life. She thus decides to apply for a secretarial position at a neighboring insurance office run by the sleek, fast-talking Louis Echard (Duris, sharp and sprightly), who’s impressed by both her superhuman typing skills and killer looks. Before long, he takes Rose under his wing as his protegee, training her for a regional secretary competition and moving her into his country mansion, where she’s swept into a daily regimen of extreme typewriting and unrequited romance.

The bond the two form is not unlike that of Don Draper and Peggy Olson -- hairstyles and smoking habits included -- and Rose’s climb to a higher social status is reminiscent of Peggy's evolution from clerk to copywriter. The difference here is that while the Mad Men duo ultimately transforms into a surrogate father-daughter team, the two Frenchies clearly have the hots for each other. Yet Louis is incapable of closing the deal, blocked by an enduring affection for his childhood sweetheart (Berenice Bejo) and memories of serving in the French Resistance during WWII.

While the love story is meant to fuel much of the action, it’s often overshadowed by the thrill of the training sessions and typing competitions, which Roinsard films as if they were some kind of office combat sport. Cutting between the competing secretaries as they pound out keystrokes and slam back their typewriter carriages, the director and editors Laure Gardette and Sophie Reine endow these sequences with the nail-biting suspense of a finale at Roland Garros, making them the real highlights of the movie.

On the other hand, the romantic drama tends to wear out its welcome sometime after the midway mark, and a sure sign that the team has run out of ideas is a later scene that imitates a famous sequence from Hitchcock’s Vertigo, down to the lighting, music and camera placement. The Artist of course did the same when it resuscitated Bernard Herrmann’s score for its finale, so it comes as no surprise that Roinsard used members of the cast and crew from that movie to bring his project to life.

But for all the earnestness with which the filmmakers replicate the muted colors and attitudes of the post-war era, they ultimately fail to say anything truly interesting about either the past or the present, resulting in a work that feels as superficial as it does slick. As Louis’ expat buddy, Bob (Shaun Benson), explains at one point, “America is for business, France is for love,” and there are times when Populaire seems to be channeling its love of movies simply as a means to achieve Hollywood clout.

Alongside the many craft highlights is a buoyant score by Rob and Emmanuel d’Orlando (Making Plans for Lena) and a soundtrack filled with French oldies by Jacqueline Boyer, Jack Ary and Les Chausettes Noires, whose frontman Eddy Mitchell makes a cameo as Louis’ despotic dad.

 

Production companies: Les Productions du Tresor, France 3 Cinema, France 2 Cinema, Mars Films, Wild Bunch Panache Productions, La Compagnie Cinematographique, RTBF

Cast: Romain Duris, Deborah Francois, Berenice Bejo, Shaun Benson, Melanie Bernier, Nicolas Bedos, Miou-Miou, Eddy Mitchell

Director: Regis Roinsard

Screenwriters: Regis Roinsard, Daniel Presley, Romain Compingt

Producer: Alain Attal

Executive producer: Xavier Amblard

Director of photography: Guillaume Schiffman

Production designer: Sylvie Olive

Music: Rob d’Orlando, Emmanuel d’Orlando

Costume designer: Charlotte David

Editors: Laure Gardette, Sophie Reine

Sales agent: Wild Bunch

No rating, 111 minutes