• The Hollywood Reporter on LinkedIn
  • Follow THR on Pinterest

How Tim Goodman Fared in Last Season's TV Predictions

Whitney
NBC
"Whitney"

THR's chief television critic was mostly right about which shows would last but missed the mark on a few he pegged to fail, including "Revenge" and "Whitney."

Do we want to revisit last season? Fine. You can't embarrass me.

As I look back on the odds I put on fall 2011’s shows, I realize I’m a terrible oddsmaker more than a terrible predictor of failure. I knew Pan Am had no future, but I laid odds of it getting canceled at 20-1. Shouldn’t that have been 5-1 if I was so certain?

PHOTOS: Tim Goodman Gives the Odds on Which Fall 2012 Shows Will Survive

I was mostly right about shows I thought would survive but missed on CBS’ A Gifted Man (didn’t like it but thought CBS would make it work); The CW’s Secret Circle (didn’t like it, but when does The CW cancel anything?); and Fox’s Allen Gregory (hated it but thought Fox treated animation with kid gloves — oops).

But here’s where I was wrong: I had NBC’s Whitney down for sure death. Apparently, NBC will keep anything. I liked Grimm but didn’t expect it to last.

STORY: 'Glee,' 'Community,' 'Voice' vs. 'X Factor' and the Season's 5 Biggest Question Marks

But I was most wrong on the subject of Revenge. I liked the pilot but thought it would get crushed at 10 p.m. Oh well.