Spain's Proposed Intellectual Property Law Finds Little Support
According to the Coalition’s General Manager Carlota Navarrete, the vague wording of the bill along with the fact that the bill turns a blind eye to the infractions caused by links and webpages, makes it useless.
“The fact that it doesn’t see links as part of the formula for infringing on rights, makes it clear that it won’t work,” Navarrete said. “If what they really want to do is to improve the instruments to be able to fight against piracy, then it needs to include some key improvements.”
At the top of the list of improvements for Navarrete?
The ability to block or close webpages once they have been detected and reported and that the wording of the law is clear.
The wording is actually one of the biggest complaints—and was highlighted by the Counsel in its December report, which called it “vague” and “ambiguous.”
One example is the fact that the definition of whether a link infringes on rights depends on the volume of access to the link or page.
“What is a lot? What is enough? Who decides what is a lot? Damage is considered damage above what level of access,” asks Navarrete. “If I don’t know what is the required level, how do I know if it is reportable. I have no way of knowing the requirements.”
Additionally, the rights holders want an independent committee to supervise the situation.
The rights holders have a strong ally in the U.S. Ambassador to Spain, James Costos, whose role as an HBO executive has made him particularly outspoken on piracy in Spain.
“Innovation cannot flourish without a legal framework to protect the works of creators. However, combating piracy requires more than just law enforcement. Along with an effective legal system, it requires educated consumers and convenient access to legal content,” the ambassador said last month at Spain’s Third Annual Intellectual Property Conference.
“We appreciate Spain’s commitment to making changes that will create a more IPR-friendly environment, one able to address emerging copyright, trademark, and patent infringement concerns,” he said.
To support Spain’s efforts, the United States is drafting a "memorandum of understanding" between the two governments to facilitate information sharing in intellectual property cases. Ambassador Costos has said that the United States looks forward to more of this collaboration with the Spanish government, and to the growing cooperation between American and Spanish businesses in the entertainment, digital economy, and healthcare sectors in the coming years. “By working together to build a strong IPR framework that not only protects rights but embraces the new possibilities created by technology, the United States and Spain can promote innovation, entrepreneurship, jobs, and growth in both our countries.”
At the moment, the bill is set to go before the cabinet in the coming weeks. Time will tell if the government will go forward with the present form of the bill or heed warnings and rewrite the bill into a stronger took to fight piracy and illegal downloads in Spain.