TCA 2012: From Jimmy Kimmel to Jeff Probst, TV's Winners and Losers

Mariah Carey
Mariah Carey
 

This story first appeared in the August 10 issue of The Hollywood Reporter magazine.

Fox

Fox might have finished the season atop the ratings charts again, but the network’s cash cow American Idol is beginning to fray after 11 seasons. And shake-ups at Idol and The X Factor -- with Demi Lovato and Britney Spears replacing Paula Abdul and Nicole Scherzinger on the latter -- mean that executives must pay inordinate attention to its expensive unscripted franchises. That said, the network has fielded two promising comedies in the critically praised Ben & Kate and the more uneven but generally liked The Mindy Project. Drama, however, could prove to be Fox’s Achilles’ heel, with this fall’s single hourlong entry, The Mob Doctor, mostly underwhelming critics.

PHOTOS: The Scene at TCA's Summer Press Tour 2012: Day 4

Best Panel

Ben & Kate: Creator Dana Fox had the room in stitches with stories about her meddlesome brother, the “Ben” in the title.

Worst Panel

The Mob Doctor: After a morning filled with Mariah Carey and the always-endearing Mindy Kaling, this drama panel lacked big reveals and much-needed energy.

Savviest Move

Closing Carey’s roughly $18 million Idol deal before the presentation, which allowed Fox chief Kevin Reilly to phone her from the stage (and to defang reporters ready to pounce on the show’s judge uncertainties and faltering ratings).

Biggest Misstep

Not finding a way to fly Simon Cowell and Spears in from Miami. Yes, they’re busy with X Factor auditions, but this show needs viewers, and reporters need interviews.

NBC

With a slate that has been greeted mostly with critical shrugs, NBC might find its Super Bowl-induced reprieve from the ratings cellar to be temporary. Chairman Bob Greenblatt touted four shows returning for a second season -- Smash, Grimm, Up All Night and Whitney -- which isn’t a total bust, but none is an out-of-the-box hit. In a moment of candor, he acknowledged that the network needs to be more inclusive, especially when it comes to its brand-defining Thursday night comedies, which “tend to be a little bit more narrow and a little bit more sophisticated than you might want for a real broad audience.” To that end, Animal Practice, with its superstar monkey Crystal, could be just the type of crowd-pleaser NBC needs.

Best Panel

The New Normal: Love him or hate him, executive producer Ryan Murphy knows how to get a group buzzing. In his 30 minutes onstage, he dropped newsy tidbits about his life (he used to be a garden designer -- and NBC’s entertainment president Jennifer Salke was an early client) and his plans for the show (the group One Million Moms, which announced a boycott of the series, will figure in the plot).

STORY: TCA 2012 ABC Recap: 'Modern Family' Still M.I.A., But There's Always Bristol Palin

Worst Panel

Chicago Fire: The drama is straight from the Dick Wolf playbook: civil servants doing dangerous work. But Wolf insisted he’s breaking the mold, saying, “There are very few franchises that give you the opportunity to explore character.” Is Wolf not familiar with the current golden age of TV drama?

Savviest Move

Enlisting Sarah Palin. Palin’s husband, Todd, ostensibly was one of the “stars” on the military-themed Stars Earn Stripes panel. But the appearance of the GOP lightning rod -- dressed in a body-hugging olive-green dress and gladiator platform sandals -- turned the poolside afterparty into a battle for attention between her and the Animal Practice monkey.

Biggest Misstep

Not inviting returning stars. Yes, FriendsMatthew Perry was there for fall comedy Go On, but for all the carping the media does about NBC, the network isn’t short on beloved stars: Nick Offerman, Amy Poehler, John Krasinski, Ed Helms, Joel McHale, Jimmy Fallon. A reminder about that stable of talent wouldn’t have hurt.

ABC

ABC boasts several returning shows with distinctive profiles (sudsy thriller Revenge, fairy tale hit Once Upon a Time and edgy comedies Suburgatory and Don’t Trust the B---- in Apt. 23), but none is the type of Modern Family-like monster hit that will cure ratings concerns. As with last season, ABC president Paul Lee will roll out a new slate of well-received series (Nashville, Last Resort) and head-scratchers (Reba McEntire’s Malibu Country, aliens-next-door comedy The Neighbors). Although Lee stressed the need to add more “blocks” to his schedule, he sidestepped questions about his lack of reality hits since Dancing With the Stars premiered nearly 10 years ago.

Best Panel

The Emmy panel with host Jimmy Kimmel, who gave critics reason to be excited by skewering FX’s decision to call American Horror Story a “miniseries,” Jay Leno’s lack of “feelings” and a generally “shallow” Hollywood.

STORY: TCA 2012: ABC's Paul Lee Talks Broad Appeal of New Dramas, Reality Failures and 'Modern Family'

Worst Panel

The executive session with Lee: With no news to report in the since-concluded Modern Family salary negotiations, Lee found four different ways to say the same thing: “We’re hopeful.” The remainder was devoted to his “love” for nearly everything on his schedule.

Savviest Move

Trotting out the impressive collection of returning contestants -- truly, the A-list of the D-list -- who will compete on Dancing With the Stars: All-Stars. Bristol Palin’s one-liners alone — “I like gays” — generated much-needed media attention.

Biggest Misstep

Not hosting an ABC comedy panel. It’s never a bad idea to remind the media what you’re good at. Modern Family’s Steven Levitan and Christopher Lloyd attended but were left to chat with reporters on their own.

CBS

Longtime chief Nina Tassler has proved the Charlie Sheen saga was but a temporary distraction at a network defined by stability. CBS heads into fall with three new dramas and one comedy. Newcomers Vegas (with Dennis Quaid) and Elementary have been relatively well-received by critics (which really doesn’t mean much for CBS), while Made in Jersey mostly has produced eye rolls for evoking a stereotypical portrayal of the Garden State. Meanwhile, the Max Mutchnick-David Kohan comedy Partners -- about best friends, one gay, one straight -- raised questions about its own use of stereotypes.

Best Panel

Partners: Will & Grace creators Mutchnick and Kohan managed to get the room laughing (Kohan absolutely was not -- or absolutely was -- an athlete in high school, depending on who was talking). Now the question is, can they get the room to watch?

STORY: TCA 2012: Don't Worry About NBC Going Dumb (Analysis)

Worst Panel

Jeff Probst: Mere weeks away from his talk show’s Sept. 10 launch, the Survivor host failed to adequately explain what his new daytime effort is all about. (FYI, “Saying yes to the adventures in your life” doesn’t mean anything.)

Savviest Move

Six months earlier, Tassler caused a stir when her team announced she wouldn’t be presenting at TCA. The press corps revolted, and she capitulated. This time around, she not only willingly appeared for the Q&A but did so with a prop (a stuffed monkey) and humor: “It’s been a TCA full of cell phone announcements from the stage, monkeys, Sarah Palin, renegotiations,” she said, referencing the Modern Family situation. “I couldn’t resist.”

Biggest Misstep

STORY: TCA 2012: Jason O'Mara Blasts Fox for 'Premature' 'Terra Nova' Cancellation

Not ending the Probst session a few minutes earlier. From the man who noted “publicists hate when I open my mouth” came the story of how he got the Survivor gig over Phil Keoghan, who had interviewed with CBS minutes before him. “Phil made the mistake of going first,” recalled a gloating Probst. “I sat there and thought, ‘Never let me in that room after you leave because I will close the deal.’ ”

comments powered by Disqus