• The Hollywood Reporter on LinkedIn
  • Follow THR on Pinterest

BearCity 2: Film Review

Bear City 2 Screengrab - H 2012

The Bottom Line

Like many parties, this film about a gay bachelor party during Provincetown's Bear Week goes on for too long.

Director-screenwriter:

Doug Langway

Cast:

Joe Conti, Gerald McCullouch, Stephen Guarino, Kathy Najimy

Provincetown's Bear Week is the colorful setting for this gay romantic comedy.

If you walk into BearCity2: The Proposal thinking that you’re about to see a nature documentary, then you’re clearly not this film’s target audience.

A sequel to 2010’s BearCity, this comedy continues the story of that film’s central couple, Tyler (Joe Conti) and the older Roger (Gerald McCullouch), who are soon to be headed down the aisle. Cue a bachelor party trip to — where else? — Provincetown, during Bear Week, where hirsute, brawny and overweight gay men go to party.

The ensuing complications — Tyler’s straitlaced parents experience culture shock, with the father finding himself constantly referred to as “Daddy” for not quite the reason he imagines — will be familiar to anyone who’s seen Sex and the City, or indeed any romantic comedy of the last few decades.

REVIEW: 'Life of Pi'

Director/screenwriter Doug Langway certainly seems to know his milieu, depicted here in a freewheeling, fun way that should do wonders to boost Provincetown tourism, not that it needs any help. The endless cavorting and quipping is occasionally interrupted by dramatic moments involving commitment issues and, in the film’s most timely element, the effects of the legalization of gay marriage on long-term relationships.

Unfortunately, the thin storyline isn’t substantial enough to sustain the nearly two-hour running time. Despite the profusion of witty one-liners -- many delivered by the very funny Stephen Guarino as the couple’s wisecracking friend who has relationship problems of his own -- staleness sets in quickly. It’s only partly alleviated by the presence of the winning Kathy Najimy as a den mother-type B&B proprietor and a procession of cameos ranging from drag performer Varla Jean Merman to filmmaker Kevin Smith. If the latter didn’t happen to be straight, he would clearly have no trouble finding a date among this crowd.

Opens Sept. 28 (TLA Releasing)

Production: BearCity Limits II

Cast: Gerald McCullouch, Joe Conti, Stephen Guarino, Brian Keane, Gregory Gunter, James Martinzez, Susan Mosher, Jason Stuart, Richard Riehle, Kathy Najimy

Director/screenwriter/editor: Doug Langway

Producers: Jim Lande, Tracy Utley

Executive producers: David Stephen Martin, Henry White

Director of photography: Michael Hauer

Costume designer:  Lydia Popper

Composers: Mark Andersen, Peter Calandra

Not rated, 110 min