Inseparable: Busan Film Review
Busan International Film Festival, A Window on Asian Cinema
Kevin Spacey, Daniel Wu, Beibi Gong, Ni Yang, Peter Stormare
Kevin Spacey plays a mysterious ex-pat living in China in the writer-director Dayyan Eng’s first Chinese movie with an American star.
Writer-director Dayyan Eng’s Inseparable is definitely a crossover film but it never makes up its mind what it wants to cross over to. It claims to be the first fully funded Chinese film with an American star in Kevin Spacey. Then it’s a black comedy with conflicting urges toward satire on one hand and fantasy on the other so its genre is hard to pin down.
After a ride on the festival circuit following its Busan premiere, the film reps a marketing challenge. Perhaps Chinese and other Asian territories might be curious about the mix of actors, languages and genres. But Spacey isn’t necessarily a draw in Western markets for a Chinese film likely to wind up in art houses even though Inseparable really isn’t an art film per se.
It starts off well enough with Spacey playing Chuck, a mysterious ex-pat living in a large Chinese city, who comes to the rescue of an apartment building neighbor, Li (Daniel Wu), about to commit suicide. A supremely confident man with a lot of practical although mischievous ideas about how to cope with the stresses of life, Chuck takes Li under his wings.
Since Li speaks fluent English and Chuck’s Mandarin “blows,” to use Chuck’s own description, the film mostly is in English but reverts to Chinese for all scenes without Spacey. Meanwhile subtitles in Mandarin and English run concurrently no matter what language is being spoken.
Li’s despondency has arisen over dual tragedies in his life that has also estranged him from his gorgeous though moody wife Pang (Beibi Gong). Plus he is under pressure at work from his dragon lady boss (Ni Yang) to lie at a government hearing as the company is about to issue an IPO.
Under Chuck’s guidance, Li creates a super hero alter ego, that of an anti-corruption crime fighter complete with a costume somewhere between Batman and Captain China. (Well, it wouldn’t be Captain America, now would it?) Chuck comes along as his sidekick albeit with a much better costume.
This is perhaps the most prescient element to Eng’s screenplay as disgust with corruption has reached record levels in China and indeed throughout Asia especially in India. The film gets at this “corruption fighting” awkwardly though with Li following up on leads based on investigations by his journalist-wife. In each case, it appears Pang has done most of the work. The goofiness of two men in masks and capes playing truth crusaders never really plays well on screen. The super-hero send-up is getting old now and this one never finds its footing.
Then the movie enters an even stranger mode. A shrink convinces Li — and possibly the audience — that much of what he is experiencing is a figment of his imagination, a brief psychotic disorder if you will. But from here on in, you’re never quite sure what is “real” and what is not. If Chuck is not real, then maybe Li’s wife isn’t either. Then Li’s dead goldfish starts talking to him.
So the film progresses from a buddy movie to a super-hero satire and then a sci-fi fantasy about levels of reality. Left somewhat behind although still the connecting tissue of the comedy is the idea of anti-corruption crusaders. With hindsight, this may have been the element that needed further development.
Instead the film gets distracted by Li attacking a poor street vendor and his wife whom he mistakenly believes to be peddling toxic tofu. It pretty much goes off the rails from this point forward. And while there is a further twist in real/unreal quandary battling it out in Li’s mind, some audience members may give up on the whole question.
However, Spacey is just right in this role, playing a possibly imaginary character with a believable earnestness and genuine concern for his neighbor’s well being. Li takes a while to find his character, playing the schlemiel with a little too much slapstick at the beginning before settling into a convincing portrait of a drowning man grasping any life-savor he can. Beibi Gong is stunningly beautiful and certainly seems like a competent actress but her role is too ephemeral.
What the Taiwan-born, American- and Beijing Film Academy-educated filmmaker fails to do is establish the right tone to convey both the silliness and seriousness of his concept. Mixing the corruption-fighting theme with mental illness never really meshes as a consequence. There was no doubt a solid idea for a film lurking in the over broad dark comedy, and landing Spacey was a definite coup. But the film feels like a rough first draft rather than a smooth final one.
All technical credits are accomplished. Thierry Argobast’s cinematography and the use of locations in Guangzhou and Guangdong are particularly outstanding.
Venue: Busan International Film Festival, A Window on Asian Cinema
Production companies: Trigger Street Productions, Colordance Pictures, Fantawild Pictures
Cast: Kevin Spacey, Daniel Wu, Beibi Gong, Ni Yang, Peter Stormare, Kenneth Tsang, Mo Zhang
Director/screenwriter/editor: Dayyan Eng
Producers: Dayyan Eng, David U. Lee,
Executive producers: Dana Brunetti, Jason Han, Ming Li, Kevin Spacey, Steven
Director of photography: Thierry Argobast
Production designer: Thomas Chong
Music: Eric Lee Harper, Nathan Wang
Costume designer: Xu Laurence
No rating, 97 minutes
- Bryan Cranston’s Makeup Artist Really Went All the Way for His LBJ Look
- Partner, Let Me Upgrade You: Hulu Finally Offers a Commercial-Free Option
- Two of Your Favorite TV Actresses Might Be in the New Star Wars
- Samantha Bee’s Full Frontal Teaser Has the Cojones Needed to Take on Those Late-Night Dudes