• The Hollywood Reporter on LinkedIn
  • Follow THR on Pinterest

Rabbit Hole -- Film Review

Rabbit Hole
Lionsgate

The Bottom Line

Deep-dish drama, not without its rewards, but a little too self-conscious for its own good.

Venue:

Toronto International Film Festival

Cast:

Nicole Kidman, Aaron Eckhart, Dianne Wiest, Miles Teller

Director:

John Cameron Mitchell

Screenwriter/based on the play by:

David Lindsay-Abaire

TORONTO -- John Cameron Mitchell takes a break from shepherding his sexually charged writing to the screen to direct David Lindsay-Abaire's adaptation of his Pulitzer-winning play, "Rabbit Hole," an intense, intimate story of a couple reeling from the loss of their young son.

This extreme change of pace allows Mitchell to burrow deeply into a more grounded kind of drama than is his forte. Nicole Kidman and Aaron Eckhart deliver performances that are like raw wounds, where nothing either one can say or do will blot out relentless memories and pain.

"Rabbit Hole" will win its share of accolades, but will it win audiences? The small screen better accommodates this kind of concentrated tragedy; in a cinema, the story becomes like those support-group sessions the couple attends: The film does achieve moments of catharsis, but it can be heavy going.

The story begins eight months after a traffic accident kills Becca (Kidman) and Howie's (Eckhart) boy. The more the couple plays "normal," the more the effort fails. Becca tries to eradicate all signs of her son, while Howie reaches out to family and friends.

The group sessions barely help. Too much talk of God for Becca, and though he won't admit it, wallowing in grief isn't doing Howie any good, either.

The story pulls in other characters -- Becca's mother (Dianne Wiest), who also lost a son, and a sister (Tammy Blanchard), whose pregnancy seems like a rebuke to Becca.

Finally, Becca reaches out and to the most surprising person. She happens to see and then makes contact with the high school student (Miles Teller) whose car struck her son. The two discover they share a common grief over the accident. The youth is developing a comic book that deals with parallel universes, of other places where a sad person might be happy and a little boy might not lose his life.

Meanwhile, Howie has his own secret sharer, a woman (Sandra Oh) from group, who has become something of a long-term griever. You realize this couple is gradually coming apart by creating separate lives.

Lindsay-Abaire knows his way around such grief, what things feel like and how best intentions go very wrong. His writing carefully pinpoints the moment where bottled-up rage will explode or the smallest incident can trigger a complete loss of control.

However, "Rabbit Hole" traps its audience inside this prison of guilt and recrimination. The drama has its own relentlessness. Every scene is about the couple's tragedy. Lines of dialogue inevitably have double meanings. Not even a dog gets walked without this being about the lost child.

In this way, the writing is too self-aware. The film cries out for moments that are not about the couple's search for re-engagement. Can't a man simply walk a dog?

Kidman grabs the central focus of the story as the more distraught of the two. The performance is riveting because she essentially plays the entire film at two levels, the surface everyday life and then what is turning over and over again in her mind.

Eckhart's outgoing husband, who isn't afraid to admit to his pain, nicely balances the tightly wound wife. He's open to whatever works -- but nothing does. So frustration compounds his anguish.

Wiest's mother is one that never loses patience with her daughter because she of all people understands. Teller gives a steady, somber performance as a young man still in a state of shock, whose whole life has gone off-kilter in a single moment.

Mitchell's crew does solid work in rendering an almost-too-perfect bedroom community outside New York. Then again, this is all part of the film's self-awareness: No matter how safe and comfy your surroundings, the film insists, everything in an instant can disappear down a rabbit hole.

Venue: Toronto International Film Festival
Production: Olympus Pictures/BlossomFilms/Odd Lot Pictures
Cast: Nicole Kidman, Aaron Eckhart, Dianne Wiest, Miles Teller, Tammy Blanchard, Sandra Oh, Giancarlo Esposito
Director: John Cameron Mitchell
Screenwriter/based on the play by: David Lindsay-Abaire
Producers: Leslie Urdang, Dean Vanech, Nicole Kidman, Per Saari, Gigi Pritzker
Executive producers: Daniel Revers, Bill Lischak, Linda McDonough, Brian O'Shea
Director of photography: Frankie DeMarco
Production designer: Kalina Ivanov
Music: Anton Sanko
Costume designer: Ann Roth
Editor: Joe Klotz
No rating, 92 minutes
Sales: CAA