Jay-Z Loses Round in Legal Fight Over ‘Big Pimpin’ Sample
Heirs of Egyptian film composer are asserting “moral rights” in a composition.
Hip-hop superstar Jay-Z is facing a lawsuit over claims that the mogul’s megahit song “Big Pimpin” violates the “moral rights” of heirs of a 1960s Egyptian film composer. In a decision Tuesday, a California federal judge ruled that the plaintiff has standing to pursue a lawsuit.
What is it with hip-hop producers sampling decades-old film music and then getting into legal trouble?
In March, we covered how Timbaland escaped a lawsuit for illegally sampling a 1967 Bollywood tune thanks to odd Indian copyright laws. Now, Jay-Z is in hot water for sampling a musical composition “Khosara, Khosara,” originally recorded for use in the 1960 Egyptian film Fata Ahlami. So far, Jay-Z isn’t nearly as fortunate as Timbaland was.
The original composition was created by Baligh Hamdy, and the copyright interests passed down to his four children upon his death in 1993. One of those children, Osama Ahmed Fahmy, is the plaintiff in this case against Shawn Carter (Jay-Z), EMI Publishing, MTV Networks, Paramount Pictures, UMG Recordings, Warner Music and many others.
In 1995, the Hamdy children licensed the right to mechanically reproduce "Khosara, Khosara" for sound recordings. Jay-Z and his team believe they acquired proper license to use the music.
That's where Egyptian copyright law enters the picture.
The plaintiff says that to the extent the defendants obtained a license of the song for the 2000 hit “Big Pimpin,” it was merely what Egyptians call “economic rights” and only pertained to reproduction, performance or distribution of the work “without alteration.”
Egyptian copyright law also confers to owners “moral rights” over copyrighted work, which, according to the plaintiff's experts, can’t be disposed of like “economic rights.” Basically, if Jay-Z wished to “mutilate” the original song by sampling it, looping it and adding his lyrics, the plaintiff argues he needed to get the express permission of each of Hamdy's four children. (Moral rights aren’t a completely unrecognized concept in the U.S. but rarely factor heavily, especially in copyright cases.)
The defendants tried to waive this lawsuit away by saying that U.S. courts don’t have subject matter jurisdiction over Egyptian “moral rights." In a decision (below), Judge Christina Snyder seems willing to entertain the nuances of Egyptian law. She rules that the moral rights didn't descend to Hamdy's heirs, but left stand larger questions over use of the sample. That doesn’t mean that the plaintiff will ultimately be successful, but the judge rules that there is standing to bring the case and there will have to be further fact-finding to determine “whether the use of Khosara Khosara was outside the scope of the licenses at issue."
Here’s the music video for the Jay-Z song in question, which Rolling Stone called one of the top 500 songs of all time, as well as the latest decision:
E-mail: email@example.com; Twitter: @eriqgardner
2014 Emmy Awards
- From Filmore East To The Moon: Chats with ABB's Jaimoe, CPD's Steve Perry, POTM's Shear Brothers and Cris Cab...Plus!
- After Reading This, You'll Never Look At The Roosevelts The Same Way Again
- Angelina Jolie's Wedding Dress Revealed On The Cover Of People Magazine
- Carrie Underwood Announces Pregnancy