Chris Daughtry

He may be Idol's bestselling rocker, but Chris Daughtry from McLeansville, North Carolina, had his own stint in the bottom two while competing in season five (after singing Louis Armstrong's eternally optimistic "What a Wonderful World"). Fortunately, there were far more standing ovation-worthy bows by the former car mechanic. From Bon Jovi's "Wanted Dead or Alive" to Creed's "What If", and on two multiplatnum alums since his fourth-place finish, it goes to show: When raw and grungy rock is your calling card, stick to it.