'Ghost in the Shell': These Movies Stole Its Thunder Years Ago
Over 20 years ago, director Mamoru Oshii's Ghost in the Shell was a groundbreaking animated adaptation of the popular manga series and a post-cyberpunk, existentialist projection of a possible future, one dominated by the use of artificial intelligence, terrorism, cyber-criminals and cyborgs. In 1995, these ideas weren't just innovative, they were bold speculations of the future, creating a compelling, fully fleshed-out world jam-packed with complicated philosophical and cultural implications. Ghost in the Shell embraced these ideas, tackling them head on, but despite its innovation, the film had trouble finding an audience of theatergoers, DVD customers and critics alike.
But Oshii's cult masterpiece did capture the eyes of a very specific audience — other innovative filmmakers, from the Wachowskis to Steven Spielberg. Those who have seen Ghost in the Shell know that all of its distinctions would eventually find a way into some of the most popular work of science fiction over the past two decades.
Heat Vision breakdown
But with so many imitators and its influence already reflected writ large across Western science fiction, can the Ghost in the Shell remake still pack the same genre-busting punch its original did so many years ago?
In the early days of The Matrix's birth, the Wachowskis were famously reported to have approached producer Joel Silver, saying, "We want to do that [Ghost in the Shell] in live action." While The Matrix (and its various sequels) turned out not to be a straight adaptation of Oshii's animated film, it did incorporate a good number of ideas from the pic, so much that even the making-of features on The Matrix DVD provided a side-by-side comparison with Ghost in the Shell. Both films use martial arts and speed-ramped action sequences as a launching pad to explore existential questions. In addition, in both films, a virtual/simulated reality plays an important role; the Wachowskis even appropriated Ghost in the Shell's digital "rain" of green numbers.
Both The Matrix and James Cameron's Avatar adopted Ghost in the Shell's idea that people might plug in to a larger network or "web" through the back of their head, even down to the familiar connection sound effect. One of the complexities of Ghost in the Shell is the idea and questions surrounding the possibility for one to transfer one's consciousness or soul into a new "avatar." Cameron's film is built around this idea, even briefly delving into a sort of Buddhist philosophical ideal that one could fully become a part of a greater universal consciousness, one of the key philosophies behind Ghost in the Shell's complex conclusion.
Spielberg acquired the rights to produce a Ghost in the Shell remake through DreamWorks and ultimately found a way to incorporate some of the ideas from the film into his 2001 Stanley Kubrick collaboration A.I. Artificial Intelligence. There he questioned the social and moral complications of human/robot interfaces and asked whether or not a robot can have a soul. It's an idea — and a horrifying conceit — central to Ghost in the Shell, one that has continued to resurface in popular sci-fi films of the past decade, from 2004's I, Robot to 2015's Ex Machina.
Not only was 1995's Ghost in the Shell cinematically inspirational, many of its ideas about technology have become prophetic about how we interact with our modern world. While we might not be plugging in to the internet through our necks, the idea of mobile interconnected devices is anything but science fiction. Nor is the idea of alternate digital realities; just in the past year or two virtual reality headsets have found their way into millions of homes across the globe, ushering in a new age of alternative digital realities.
This is all to say that a straight remake of Ghost in the Shell faces an interesting hurdle the original film never had to mount. Many of its ideas have become so fundamental to modern science fiction and modern life that they could be seen as borderline cliche, after once being heralded as revolutionary. We've seen sequels to 300 and Sin City tank hard after their cinematic ideas and styles were copied by other films, making them less special.
Rupert Sanders' remake of Ghost in the Shell has received mixed reviews, though it's fared a little better than 2014's 300: Rise of an Empire or Sin City: A Dame to Kill For.
Perhaps the one element that the new Ghost in the Shell pic should have embraced the most, to make it stand out from its contemporaries, is its Eastern ideas and philosophies. Up until now, the West has viewed the most revolutionary elements of Ghost in the Shell through a Western lens. Embracing its roots could have made the film more interesting to a Western audience that had already familiarized itself with its previously most unique elements. But the movie did not go that route — and even failed to embrace its Eastern roots in its casting. As The Hollywood Reporter's Jordan Mintzer wrote in his review, the film traded substance for style and is "a heavily computer-generated enterprise with more body than brains, more visuals than ideas."
by Etan Vlessing
by Aaron Couch
by Duane Byrge, Mike Barnes