'Dancing With the Stars' Winner: Melissa Rycroft, Tony Dovolani Crowned Top 'All-Stars'

Dancing with the Stars: All-Stars Rycroft Dovolani 11/19 - H 2012

Dancing with the Stars: All-Stars Rycroft Dovolani 11/19 - H 2012

Dancing With the Stars has named its ultimate All-Star.

The 15th season, which brought back a whopping 13 former competitors to vie for the bragging rights of being named the winningest castmember, ended on Tuesday night with what doubled as the series' only all-female finale.

PHOTOS: The Cast of 'Dancing With the Stars: All-Stars'

And between celebrated rule-breakers Shawn Johnson and Derek Hough, flirtatious Kelly Monaco and Val Chmerkovskiy and the duo that never won, Melissa Rycroft and Tony Dovolani, the trophy went to the first-timers.

Rycroft, a second runner-up in her season, and Dovolani, a seasoned pro who never made it all the way on the show, walked away with the blinged-out mirrorball -- thanks in large part to their top score and praised freestyle. "You’ve been my greatest pleasure to watch," judge Len Goodman told the duo. "You’ve been fantastic."

Talking to reporters after the show, Rycroft mentioned about the camaraderie of the season -- and how she never really expected to top Johnson.

"When it was our name called, I just went, 'Oh, my gosh, how did this just happen?' " she said. "The support behind us the entire season it feels good. I felt the cast was genuinely happy for us."

Dovolani seemed equally thrilled. "I’ve paid my dues, but it was worth the entire 14 seasons to get somebody like Melissa," he said. "It was worth this unbelievable moment, this incredible ride. All of the stars have to align sometimes, and tonight they all did."