'Lying Game': Charisma Carpenter Previews Season 2 Finale, Talks Renewal Chances

Lying Game Charisma Carpenter - H 2013
Felicia Graham/ABC Family

[Warning: Some spoilers ahead.]

Is Rebecca to blame on The Lying Game?

The events from recent weeks are culminating in Tuesday's finale, and it all seems to point to Rebecca Sewell (Charisma Carpenter) as the guilty party. Was she the one responsible for Theresa's death? Derek's murder? Though it may look that way, there is far more to the story than meets the eye.

At the moment, it seems Rebecca's next stop could be the slammer. "Depending on the evidence, I have a sneaking suspicion I will be facing some jail time from Alec's hand," Carpenter tells The Hollywood Reporter.

VIDEO: 'The Lying Game': Theresa's Disappearance Pits Brother Against Brother

But Rebecca may not be as evil as she seems. "It'll be super surprising when you realize she's not the uber-villain she's been painted out to be," she says, "and the person [who is], you're like, 'No!' Someone you would least likely expect. I did not expect that character being the big, bad uber-villain. Who knows, maybe they're not?"

As with every closer, there will be "a few confrontations in the season finale between some pivotal people," Carpenter teases, with someone's fate possibly in question. The big question, however, is whether Emma and Sutton will out their twin status to everyone? "When will everyone find out?" Carpenter asks. "I think you have a lot to look forward to."

The season will have a shocking end "and it will not be resolved," Carpenter says. "This is a bona fide cliffhanger."

STORY: 'Lying Game's' Ryan Rottman on Season 2: 'It's Going to Get Dirty'

When asked if there has been any indication about a season three for The Lying Game, the actress admits it is "a sore subject."

"I'm not used to ever having to wait for all your episodes to air before they're willing to give a well-deserved audience a pickup," Carpenter says.

Carpenter noted the similarities in tone between lead-in Pretty Little Liars and Lying Game, both born from Sara Shepard novels, and recalled her days on Buffy the Vampire Slayer and spinoff Angel. "I feel like Lying Game is a spinoff of Pretty Little Liars," Carpenter says, adding later, "I feel like we're deserving all the support we can get."

The Lying Game wraps up season two at 9 p.m. Tuesday on ABC Family.

E-mail: Philiana.Ng@thr.com
Twitter: @insidethetube