Anatomy of a Contender: 'The Lovely Bones'
EmptyIt was October 2007, a month before filming began on "The Lovely Bones," when Fran Walsh realized she had miscast her male lead.
The co-writer/producer, along with director Peter Jackson and the rest of the filmmakers, cast Ryan Gosling and Rachel Weisz as parents of 14-year-old Susie Salmon, whose murder and journey through the "in-between" powers Alice Sebold's novel and the film. Although Gosling, then 27, had grown a beard and packed on 20 pounds to appear more convincing as the father of a teenager, he dropped out because of what was reported at the time as "creative differences."
But Walsh says that everyone agreed he was miscast.
"Ryan came to us two or three times and said, 'I'm not the right person for this role. I'm too young,' " she recalls. "And we said, 'No, no, no. We can age you up. We can thin your hair.' We were very keen.
"It wasn't until we were in preproduction and we had the cast there that it became increasingly clear: He was so uncomfortable moving forward, and we began to feel he was not right. It was our blindness, the desire to make it work no matter what."
That desire to make "Bones" work has powered the filmmakers through several obstacles on the path to awards season. Case in point: Oscar nominee Mark Wahlberg, who is a decade older and the father of three, quickly was signed to step in for Gosling.
"He has seven or eight siblings, and he understands the chaos of family," Walsh says. "He really anchored the story. He gave a solidity to the storytelling from our point of view."
Before "Bones" could become a Jackson film, the helmer needed to secure film rights.
The film unit of London-based Channel 4 first scored rights back in 2000, when "Bones" was an uncompleted manuscript. Producer Aimee Peyronnet presented three chapters of Sebold's haunting novel about the impact of a teenage girl's brutal murder to Jim Wilson, FilmFour's co-deputy of production. Wilson slipped the pages to Paul Webster, then head of FilmFour, which optioned the book.
But it wasn't until late 2002, after Tessa Ross took over the division from Webster, that the company committed to buying film rights.
"I'd read it as soon as it was published that June, and I absolutely loved it," Ross says. "I felt that Alice Sebold had the most exceptional, pure poetic voice I'd come across in a long time."
Lynne Ramsay, who directed 2002's "Morvern Callar," was hired to write and direct. But after two years, she still had not produced a workable script, Ross says. The biggest challenge was to translate to the screen Sebold's description of he "in-between," Susie's stopping-off point on the way to heaven.
As the Ramsay project stalled, Jackson became excited about the book after his partners Walsh and Philippa Boyens brought it to him soon after publication. Jackson was eager to return to an intimate drama after the megabudget spectacles of "The Lord of the Rings" trilogy and "King Kong." By then, however, the book had become a hot property -- it ultimately spent more than a year on the New York Times hardcover best-seller list and sold more than 1 million copies.
Wth Hollywood suitors knocking on FilmFour's door, Ross knew she could afford to be picky about whom she worked with.
"We, a small British company, owned the rights to material that all of America loved," Ross says. Jackson's longtime manager, Ken Kamins, was an aggressive suitor, but she initially was skeptical and wanted to develop it with a U.K. director. "Ken had said very loudly and frequently that Peter Jackson and his team absolutely loved this material."
Finally, Kamins says, Ross called him to let him know there was "a crack in the door," and he flew to London to meet with her.
"So you feel a lot of care will be taken, but you won't be out there eternally, not knowing whether you'll have a movie," Kamins says of his pitch.
Jackson says it was important for him not to be on any set time-table. "We write as many drafts as we want until we're happy with it," he says. "Bones" took "a year or two," some of it accomplished while finishing "Kong."
"It's very much an adaptation of the book," Jackson says of the shooting script. But "we changed a lot of it. The book almost goes right into the murder of Susie, but for a film, we felt that her murder would be more powerful if we'd gotten to know her and her family, so we used the murder as a traditional end of a first act.
"We also played around, in a way that we can do on film that Alice couldn't do with the book, with the identity of the murderer. We didn't want to immediately tell people who the murderer is, although it isn't a whodunit. We were able to use cinematic devices: We showed him in a crowd of people but never showed his face for the first few times."
Jackson, Walsh and Boyens completed the script in April 2007, set a beginning budget of $65 million and began the hunt for a studio partner. All studios were invited to bid except New Line, which Wingnut was challenging in court over "Rings" royalties. Kamins asked suitors to produce a marketing plan, and in early May, he received bids from DreamWorks, Universal, Sony and Warner Bros. DreamWorks won with a reported $70 million bid.
Producers cast Saoirse Ronan as Susie, Stanley Tucci as her murderer and Weisz and Gosling as her parents. Once Gosling was replaced with Wahlberg, filmmakers shot autumn scenes in Pennsylvania, then moved to summery New Zealand for more exteriors, bluescreen shooting and postproduction. There, Jackson and his team were faced with the same quandary that had challenged Ramsay -- creating a convincing "in-between" for Susie.
"The challenge of the story line is that she's not able to move on into heaven because she can't let go of the living and also she's still under the control of her killer," Jackson says. "Her body hasn't been found, and she has to free herself of the killer even after she's been murdered. It was very difficult to do on film because it's in her subconsciousness, really. It's the land of dreams."
Jackson and his team got some extra time to pull off the visuals thanks to a release-date shift. "Bones" initially was slated for a March premiere, but spring break seemed an inappropriate time for such dark subject matter. In November 2008, Jackson showed a cut of the film to Brad Grey, Rob Moore and Adam Goodman at Paramount, which had inherited the film after the studio's split from DreamWorks. (Paramount always was pegged to distribute.) It turned out to be a critical juncture.
"At that point, they decided to hold the film back to Dec. 11, and that was a blessing for us," Jackson says. "It meant we had the one thing we'd never had before, which was time in postproduction."
Promising not to increase the budget, Jackson asked for the film back to tinker with it in post. That year and a half enabled the filmmakers to drastically enhance the film, crafting a lush yet unsentimental version of Susie's "in-between."
"We started to experiment, and we drifted away from the scripted version: We moved scenes around, Saoirse did new voice-over, we found a better structure that's not the structure we wrote," Jackson says. "It has better pacing, better emotion, and it makes people cry more than before. It was a real lesson for us in what decent time in postproduction can give you."