Hollywood Flashback: Before 'La La Land,' an Original Musical Won in 1959

John Springer Collection/CORBIS/Getty Images
Leslie Caron and Louis Jourdan in 1958's 'Gigi'

'Gigi' took home a then-recording-breaking nine statuettes, including best director for Vincente Minnelli, whose daughter Liza praises the movie as "really smart big-studio entertainment."

If the oddsmakers are correct, La La Land will be the first original musical to win the best picture Oscar since 1958's Gigi, an MGM production about a singing-and-dancing Parisian courtesan that THR called "a gaily naughty fairy tale for adults." Along with best picture, Gigi took home eight other Oscars, including best director for Vincente Minnelli, in a record-breaking sweep (that lasted exactly one year, until Ben-Hur took home 11).

Liza Minnelli credits the film's success to her father's knowledge of "art, painting and literature — he was an expert at bringing all the arts into the movies," she tells THR. "Not many directors in Hollywood have that talent. Gigi is really smart big-studio entertainment."

At the time, though, THR's coverage was fixated more on the Oscars' not-so-smooth telecast, only the seventh time the awards had been on TV. The paper called the ceremony "as ragged as ever witnessed on a prime TV show." One complaint was that it ended 20 minutes early despite host Jerry Lewis' epic ad-libbing, and NBC was forced to fill time with a "sports review film." THR even wondered whether "the $900,000 cost was worthwhile." (The show's current production budget is $43 million.)

If there was one part THR liked, it was Kirk Douglas and Burt Lancaster performing a number called "It's Great Not to Be Nominated," singing lyrics such as, "Since we haven't been vested/we're not interested/But who stuck those knives in our backs?" 

This story first appeared in the Feb. 24 issue of The Hollywood Reporter magazine. To receive the magazine, click here to subscribe.

comments powered by Disqus