More scrutiny for Uni-BMG deal
EmptyThe European Commission is opening an in-depth investigation into Universal Music Group's planned takeover of BMG Music Publishing, sources said Wednesday.
"The commission will open a second-phase inquiry, and this will probably take place on Dec. 8," one source said.
The commission — the European Union's governing body — launches second-phase merger investigations if competition concerns can't be resolved during the initial one-month, first-phase inquiry.
The official commission language always refers to "serious doubts" it might have about the effect on competition, consumer choice or prices. But this is taken to mean that it simply has not had enough time to fully understand the case at hand.
"This is not surprising simply because of the complexity of the case," one antitrust attorney said. "The commission needs to gather all sorts of data about the publishing market from various sources, analyze it and take a decision: That would be almost impossible in just one month. It's easier to simply say they have 'serious doubts' and then do a proper inquiry."
It was only earlier this month that Vivendi, owner of Universal Music Publishing Group, formally asked the commission to clear its €1.63 billion ($2.1 billion) takeover of BMG Music Publishing.
The commission has sent out detailed questionnaires to various key players in the music industry, including the major labels, other publishing majors, the IFPI, independent label lobbying group Impala as well as groups representing collecting societies.
The last investigation of Europe's music publishing market took place in 2000, when the commission was asked to rule on the abortive merger between Warner and EMI. The 2004 merger between Sony and BMG pointedly failed to include their respective publishing businesses. Since the 2000 investigation, the market has changed considerably, notably thanks to the advent of digital downloads.
The investigation comes at a sensitive political time for the commission's competition services. It is just four months since the Court of First Instance, the EU's second-highest court, annulled the BMG merger with Sony when it upheld an appeal that the commission had used sloppy, cursory analyses when it approved it. Many observers expect the commission to conduct a thorough investigation to show that it has learned the lessons of the ruling — even if the final outcome is the same.
"The second-phase inquiry is entirely consistent with what is going on within the commission and the current political climate after the court ruling," an industry source said. "They have to appear purer than Caesar's wife."
BMG and Universal each have about 11% of the market. If approved, they will have a 22% combined market share — about two points more than market-leader EMI.
Vivendi beat off rivals EMI Music Publishing and Warner/ Chappell Music in September to purchase BMG Music Publishing, whose archive of more than 1 million songs includes Coldplay, Britney Spears and Justin Timberlake. BMG Music Publishing is expected to complement rather than overlap a Universal catalog that includes such artists as U2 and Elton John.