Surprisingly, the Australian pop-punk band eschewed performing their hit “She Looks So Perfect,” or their ballad “Amnesia,” and instead treated fans to a fan favorite, a cover of The Romantics’ 1979 hit “What I Like About You.”
Luke Hemmings, Michael Clifford, Calum Hood and Ashton Irwin rocked out during the high-energy song, as their fans have come to expect. They performed early in the show, and later took home the trophy for New Artist of the Year.
Watch a clip of their performance above.
This post originally appeared on Billboard.com.