Watch E.T. Help Channing Tatum Play "Box of Lies"

Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon

How did Fallon withstand this gaze?

Channing Tatum had the honor of being the first male guest to ever play "Box of Lies" with Jimmy Fallon on The Tonight Show on Wednesday.

He brought his (incredibly good-looking) game face along with him to tell both truths and lies in an attempt to stump Fallon. Chewbacca and Jell-O were involved, along with Fallon spouting gibberish about sugar on a tea bag string.

Read more Channing Tatum: '22 Jump Street's' Success Is "Such a Sham"

Tatum gets lucky when he pulls out E.T. in a sleeping bag. As expected, the stuffed toy makes for a great trump card — watch their funny interactions below.